Mental health content creators define their own ethics

Ryan Fisher-Kwan, the online content creator at her home in Toronto on August 18, 2022 (Hao Nguyen for The Washington Post)
Ryan Fisher-Kwan, the online content creator at her home in Toronto on August 18, 2022 (Hao Nguyen for The Washington Post)

In the face of explosive demand and a lack of safeguards, mental health content creators define their own ethics


Issey Moloney signed up for treatment through Britain’s National Health Service when she was just 12 years old. She was on the waiting list for four years.

Meanwhile, social media has helped her reduce loneliness, says the 17-year-old who lives in London. She has reached out to people online as the pandemic has isolated her from real-life friends. Eventually, she started creating her own content. Now, she has 5.9 million followers on TikTok – about 85 percent of them are young women between the ages of 14 and 18 – and a collection of videos about friends, relationships, and mental health.

Some of its clips are general like short relationship poem Among people with mental illness and pasta, while others treat real diagnoses, such as “Signs you might have borderline personality disorder,” or borderline personality disorder. Sometimes, people ask her to treat certain conditions. You try to research for at least a week, checking websites and message boards and doing interviews by direct message for people with a particular diagnosis. It adds a disclaimer: “Everyone deals with [panic attacks] differently and not all of them feel the same.”

She has no formal training and often talks about somewhat universal feelings, such as anxiety and depression. Commentators sometimes accuse her of being just a “teenager” or encouraging self-diagnosis.

In real life, mental health and care information is scarce. In the United States, one in three counties does not have a single licensed psychologist, according to the American Psychological Association, and Americans say cost is the biggest barrier to seeking mental health help. On the internet, however, mental health advice is everywhere: TikTok videos with #mentalhealth in the caption have garnered more than 43.9 billion views, according to analytics firm Sprout Social, and references to mental health on social media are growing every year. after a year.

The growing popularity of the topic means that mental health content creators are filling the healthcare gap. But social media apps aren’t designed to prioritize accurate and useful information, critics say, whatever content attracts the most reaction. Young people can see that their deep struggles become fodder for advertisers and self-promoters. With no roadmap even for licensed professionals, mental health innovators define their own ethics.

“I don’t want to give anyone wrong advice,” Moloney says. “I met some [followers] Who just started crying and saying “thank you” and things like that. Although it seems small, for someone else, it can make a really big impact.”

Also rates of depression and anxiety rose During a pandemic and accessible care options diminishIn this article, the creators shared a range of content including first-person accounts of life with mental illness and videos recounting symptoms of bipolar disorder. In many cases, the number of their followers has swelled.

For teens, navigating the mental health risks of Instagram is part of everyday life

Creators and viewers alike say the content is useful. They also acknowledge that adopting it involves risks such as Misinformation and harmful self-diagnosis. Some notable accounts have was criticized To share tips that most professionals do not support. Many creators sell courses and books or enter into advertising partnerships, opening the door to them conflict of interest. Lots of online content simply tells listeners what they want to hear, content creators say, and relatively rare circumstances such as Narcissistic personality disorder It receives a lot of attention, as commentators diagnose their least favorites. Because of the algorithms, people who show an interest in this type of content see more of it.

Sometimes, content creators find themselves dealing with a torrent of messages from followers or struggling to control how audiences interpret their content.

“It’s certainly strange to see myself drawn to something marketable to people defining ‘mental illness’ by, and to some extent to me, gobbling up the algorithm that encourages people to move forward in that line,” said Ryan Fisher-Kwan. On her struggles with mental illness with 225,000 followers on TikTok.” “There is definitely a concerted effort to really benefit from mental illness and especially the mental illness of young women. It’s a very marketable commodity right now.”

Although professional organizations such as the American Counseling Association cause Some social media tipsTherapists said they tend to misunderstand or ignore the demands of the creative economy. In the meantime, non-professionals can say almost anything With few consequences. The creators say that young people cannot always distinguish experts from hackers.

Said Sadaf Siddiqui, creator and licensed Instagram therapist.

Training is valuable. Such is the experience, as the creators say.

Many creators are not experts, and many say they have been failed before by experts.

Fisher-Quann’s inbox is full of the kinds of questions you whisper to your best friend in the middle of the night: Do these tough feelings mean I’m depressed? Does having a homosexual experience mean that I am gay?

If the question touches on something you tested, you might respond. Other times, messages are not answered, the 21-year-old writer and cultural critic said. He sometimes sends people to her to say they’re contemplating suicide, and she says she directs them toward professional resources. Fischer-Kwan said it hurts to know that they may not get the real-world help they need.

“Because of this institutional failure, I basically don’t feel comfortable telling people to institutionalize themselves,” she said. “But I am also very critical of capitalist platforms where people present themselves as experts and give advice that may end up being shortsighted.”

Determining who is considered an expert is not always easy. Clara Kernig, a content creator with 159,000 followers on Instagram, describes herself in her bio as an “expert at pleasing people.” She said that she got this title through experience.

She said after leaving her dream doctoral program against her family’s wishes, Kernig began learning about dependence, trauma, and “people-pleasing” from books and the Internet. She said she’s now in better health, and creates content specifically for mental health, including “5 things we think are cute and are behaviors that please people. “

“I don’t want to discredit therapists, but I also want to say there are other ways to educate people and get that information,” she said. “Maybe I’ll put something wrong, and then I hope my community and therapists will point it out to me in a loving way.”

Some creators are taking it upon themselves to challenge content that isn’t supported by search. Psychology professor Inna Kanevsky of San Diego Mesa College, a TikTok content creator with an audience of 1.1 million, often refutes what she considers irresponsible claims in videos posted by other creators. Some of the people who criticized her said that Kanevsky talks to them, invalidates their experiences or misinterprets their intentions.

“It’s funny because people will say, ‘You’re passive-aggressive,'” Kanevsky said. “And I’m like, ‘No, I’m aggressive-aggressive.’ If you post nonsense, I’ll tell you.”

Content creators control the content, not its interpretation

There is an important difference between providing therapy advice and creating relevant content, say the creators. But these lines can quickly become blurry.

In addition to posting posts to her 129,000 followers on Instagram, my friend also treated clients via a video call. They often send her posts from other mental health creators to discuss during their sessions, and she helps them evaluate the information and determine if it applies.

Posts lead to good conversations and deeper insights my friend He said. But she is concerned about where the algorithm sends people next and whether the audience gets enough time to think. She said it’s easy for people without real support to misinterpret mental health content or unfairly label themselves or others.

Dusty Chipura, who makes TikTok videos about attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), said the idea of ​​people bundling their mental health journeys into an algorithm-influenced income-verified app can be intimidating, but critics need to hit the brakes. Psychological health. She said she’s not too concerned about self-diagnosis, because perfectly healthy people are generally not the ones to browse for information about symptoms and treatments. On top of that, health care professionals usually ignore people’s concerns, she said, so many people with genuine disorders never get a formal diagnosis.

“You don’t need an ADHD diagnosis to benefit from the tips, tricks, and strategies,” Chibura said.

Nidra Glover Tawab, a licensed therapist and Instagram maker with 1.5 million followers, said the public knows to take into account context and not accept every word uttered by a creator as fact. As with any marketplace, it is the responsibility of consumers to decide whether to buy what a particular content creator sells.

Who is responsible for assessing mental health content?

In the world of online mental health guidance, there is little accountability for platforms or creators if something goes wrong.

Instagram in June Launched A pilot program called Well-being Creator Collective, which says it provides funding and education to nearly 50 US creators to help them produce content that is “responsible” for emotional well-being and self-image. The company says the program is guided by a panel of outside experts.

Linda Sharmraman, Senior Researcher and Director of the Youth, Media, and Wellbeing Research Laboratory at the Wellesley Centers for Women, In that committee said who – which In general, participants seem to be very interested in using their platforms for good.

TikTok said it is “committed to promoting a supportive environment for people who choose to share their personal wellness journeys while removing medical misinformation and other violations of our policies,” according to a spokeswoman.

“We encourage individuals to seek professional medical advice if they need support,” she said in a statement.

Ideally, social media apps should be one component of a pool of mental health resources, said Judy Miller, a researcher in the Johns Hopkins University School of Education who studies relationships between youth, technology, and stress.

“Young people need evidence-based sources of information outside the internet, from parents and schools,” Miller said.

Often, these resources are not available. It’s up to consumers to decide what mental health advice they put in stock, Fisher-Kwan said. For her, the compromise of health care providers and distorted incentives for social media platforms didn’t make that easy. But she thinks she can get better — and that her followers can, too.

“All of this has to come from a place of self-awareness and a desire to improve. Societies can be very helpful at that, but they can be very harmful for that.”

Linda Chung from San Francisco contributed to this report.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.